Authored by the expert who managed and guided the team behind the South Africa Property Pack
Yes, the analysis of Cape Town's property market is included in our pack
Cape Town consistently outperforms Johannesburg across key investment metrics, making it South Africa's premier property investment destination. Property prices in Cape Town have grown by 30% over the past five years compared to Johannesburg's modest 8.6% increase, while delivering superior international demand, lower vacancy rates, and stronger infrastructure investment despite higher initial costs.
If you want to go deeper, you can check our pack of documents related to the real estate market in South Africa, based on reliable facts and data, not opinions or rumors.
Cape Town delivers superior capital growth (30% vs 8.6% over five years), higher international buyer demand, and better infrastructure investment than Johannesburg.
While Johannesburg offers slightly higher rental yields, Cape Town's lower vacancy rates, stronger tourism returns, and lifestyle appeal create a more robust investment environment overall.
| Investment Factor | Cape Town | Johannesburg |
|---|---|---|
| 5-Year Price Growth | 30% | 8.6% |
| Average Property Price | R3.5 million | R1.3-1.5 million |
| Rental Yields | 9.42% (7-12% range) | 11.38% (9-14% range) |
| Vacancy Rate | 1.07-4.1% | 3.8-6%+ |
| International Buyer Demand | R1+ billion annually | Limited |
| Crime Index (2025) | 73.7 (prime areas safer) | 80.8 (5th highest globally) |
| Annual Growth Projection | 3-7% | 1.5-3.5% |
How much has property price growth in Cape Town outperformed Johannesburg over the past five years?
Cape Town property prices have dramatically outperformed Johannesburg with a 30% increase over the past five years compared to Johannesburg's modest 8.6% growth.
As of September 2025, the average property price in Cape Town reaches approximately R3.5 million, while Johannesburg properties average between R1.3-1.5 million. This performance gap represents one of the most significant divergences between South Africa's major property markets in recent history.
Cape Town's superior performance stems from multiple factors including international buyer demand, lifestyle migration trends, and constrained supply in prime areas. The city recorded an 8.5% year-on-year increase in January 2025 alone, compared to Johannesburg's 2.3% annual growth over the same period. Prime Cape Town suburbs like Llandudno have seen extraordinary growth of 135% since 2019, rising from R11.5 million to R27 million average prices.
This outperformance has positioned Cape Town as South Africa's strongest property market, with the Western Cape contributing 3.1 percentage points to national metropolitan inflation rates compared to Johannesburg's 0.5 percentage point contribution.
The sustained growth trajectory reflects Cape Town's emergence as a global lifestyle destination attracting both domestic semigration and foreign investment capital.
What are the current average rental yields in Cape Town compared to Johannesburg?
Johannesburg currently offers higher average rental yields at 11.38% compared to Cape Town's 9.42% as of Q2 2025.
Cape Town's rental yields range from 7.19% to 12.15%, with central areas like Woodstock and Observatory delivering exceptional yields exceeding 8%. The lower overall yields reflect higher property purchase prices rather than weak rental demand. Premium areas in Cape Town generate substantial rental income, with luxury one-bedroom units in tourist zones earning R25,000-R30,000 monthly.
Johannesburg's rental yields span from 9.15% to 16.37%, with prime northern suburbs like Sandton achieving yields at the upper end of this range. The higher yields primarily result from lower property acquisition costs rather than superior rental income. Average monthly rents in Johannesburg's city center range from R7,000-R9,000 for one-bedroom apartments, significantly below Cape Town's R10,000-R15,000 range.
While Johannesburg delivers higher gross returns, Cape Town's rental market benefits from significantly lower vacancy rates and stronger international demand. Cape Town's average vacancy rate of 1.07-4.1% compared to Johannesburg's 3.8-6%+ creates more reliable rental income streams.
The yield differential reflects market fundamentals where Cape Town prioritizes capital appreciation over income generation, while Johannesburg offers higher yields to compensate for lower growth prospects.
How strong is the demand from international buyers in Cape Town versus Johannesburg?
Cape Town dominates international buyer demand with over R1 billion in foreign purchases annually, while Johannesburg attracts limited international investment.
International buyers constitute 67% of Atlantic Seaboard sales in Cape Town, with key areas receiving sustained foreign capital from Germany, the UK, Netherlands, and the USA. Foreign investors view Cape Town as a lifestyle destination offering value relative to global property markets, particularly for second homes and investment properties.
The city's appeal to international buyers stems from its world-class amenities, stable infrastructure, and favorable exchange rates. Foreign purchasers consistently target prime coastal areas including Clifton, Camps Bay, and Sea Point, where limited supply and stunning locations create competitive bidding environments.
Johannesburg's international appeal remains primarily business-focused rather than lifestyle-driven. The city attracts some foreign investment in commercial and industrial sectors, but residential foreign buyer activity pales compared to Cape Town's sustained international demand.
Cape Town's international recognition as a tourist destination and its English-speaking environment make it significantly more accessible to foreign buyers. This sustained international demand provides crucial support for property values and creates upward pressure on prices that Johannesburg lacks.
What is the current vacancy rate for rental properties in both cities?
Cape Town maintains significantly lower vacancy rates at 1.07% overall and 3.2-4.1% in prime metro suburbs, while Johannesburg records higher vacancy rates of 3.8-6%+ across different areas.
Cape Town's low vacancy rates reflect strong rental demand driven by domestic migration, tourism, and limited housing supply. Elite areas achieve vacancy rates as low as 1%, demonstrating exceptional demand-supply dynamics. The tight rental market supports stable rental income and provides landlords with pricing power.
Johannesburg's vacancy rates vary significantly by location, with Sandton recording 3.8% and northern suburbs averaging 4.5%. Peripheral areas can exceed 6% vacancy, indicating weaker demand in less desirable locations. The higher vacancy rates reflect greater housing supply and more price-sensitive rental markets.
Cape Town's superior vacancy performance creates more predictable rental income streams for investors. Lower vacancy translates to reduced marketing costs, shorter void periods, and stronger tenant retention rates.
The vacancy differential highlights Cape Town's structural housing shortage versus Johannesburg's more balanced supply-demand dynamics, making Cape Town a more landlord-favorable market overall.
Don't lose money on your property in Cape Town
100% of people who have lost money there have spent less than 1 hour researching the market. We have reviewed everything there is to know. Grab our guide now.
How do short-term rental returns from tourism in Cape Town compare to those in Johannesburg?
Cape Town delivers substantially higher short-term rental returns with average annual Airbnb income of R427,000 ($22,000) per listing compared to Johannesburg's significantly lower tourism-driven yields.
Cape Town achieves 71% occupancy rates with average daily rates of R1,682 ($90), supported by the city's status as an international tourist destination. Premium properties in areas like the Atlantic Seaboard and City Bowl can generate significantly higher returns, with luxury units earning well above average rates.
The city's tourism infrastructure, including proximity to beaches, wine regions, and major attractions, creates year-round demand for short-term rentals. International visitors consistently seek accommodation in Cape Town's prime locations, supporting premium pricing and high occupancy rates.
Johannesburg's short-term rental market operates primarily on business travel and domestic tourism, generating far lower occupancy rates and nightly charges. The city lacks Cape Town's international tourist appeal, limiting short-term rental potential to business districts and specific event periods.
Cape Town's tourism industry provides property investors with dual income opportunities through both traditional rentals and lucrative short-term letting, creating diversification options unavailable in Johannesburg's more limited tourism market.
What are the average property taxes, transfer duties, and municipal rates in Cape Town compared to Johannesburg?
Both cities apply identical national transfer duty rates with exemptions below R1.21 million, while Cape Town experiences slightly higher municipal rate increases of 7.96% compared to Johannesburg's 4-5% hikes in 2025.
Transfer duties follow South Africa's progressive national structure: exempt below R1.21 million, reduced rates for properties between R1.2-3 million, and standard rates above R3 million. Both cities benefit equally from recent progressive relief policies designed to support first-time buyers and mid-market purchasers.
Municipal rates and property taxes show marginal differences, with Cape Town implementing a 7.96% rate increase in 2025 while Johannesburg maintained more modest 4-5% increases. However, Cape Town property owners benefit from superior service delivery and infrastructure investment that justifies higher municipal charges.
Transactional costs including legal fees, bond registration, and related expenses remain similar between cities, typically adding 8-10% to purchase prices. Cape Town's higher property values mean higher absolute costs, but the percentage remains consistent.
Despite slightly higher holding costs, Cape Town delivers significantly better value through superior infrastructure, services, and capital appreciation that more than compensates for marginal cost differences.
How does infrastructure investment, such as transport and utilities, differ between the two cities right now?
Cape Town leads South Africa with record infrastructure investment of R40 billion over 2023-2026, compared to Johannesburg's R26.2 billion three-year program starting 2025/26.
Cape Town delivered R9.5 billion in infrastructure spending during 2024/25 alone, representing the largest metropolitan infrastructure program in South Africa. Major investments focus on water security through desalination plants, transport expansion via MyCiTi bus networks, and energy grid improvements to reduce load shedding vulnerability.
The city's infrastructure strategy emphasizes resilience and service reliability, with substantial investments in supplemental water sources including aquifer development and water reuse facilities. Cape Town aims to provide at least four stages of load shedding protection through renewable energy projects and independent power purchasing.
Johannesburg's infrastructure spending primarily addresses urgent maintenance of aging assets, including road repairs, bridge restoration, and basic service upgrades. While substantial, the spending often focuses on catching up with deferred maintenance rather than transformational improvements.
Cape Town's proactive infrastructure investment creates lasting value for property owners through improved services, reduced utility disruptions, and enhanced quality of life that supports long-term property appreciation.
What are the latest crime statistics in prime residential areas of Cape Town compared to Johannesburg?
Cape Town records a crime index of 73.7 compared to Johannesburg's significantly higher 80.8, with prime residential areas in Cape Town demonstrating substantially better safety profiles than Johannesburg's top suburbs.
Johannesburg ranks as the 5th most dangerous city globally with an 80.8 crime index, where violent and property crime risks remain elevated even in premium areas like Sandton and northern suburbs. The city faces ongoing challenges with carjacking, armed robbery, and violent crime that affect residents across all socioeconomic levels.
Cape Town, while ranking 16th globally with a 73.7 crime index, concentrates crime in specific districts away from prime residential areas. The Atlantic Seaboard, City Bowl, and southern suburbs benefit from heavy private security investment and municipal safety programs that create substantially safer environments.
Prime Cape Town residential areas receive significant security infrastructure including CCTV networks, rapid response services, and community safety initiatives. Areas like Clifton, Camps Bay, and Constantia maintain safety standards comparable to international destinations, supporting their appeal to high-net-worth residents and international buyers.
The safety differential represents a crucial factor for property values, with Cape Town's prime areas offering lifestyle security that Johannesburg struggles to match despite extensive private security measures.
We did some research and made this infographic to help you quickly compare rental yields of the major cities in South Africa versus those in neighboring countries. It provides a clear view of how this country positions itself as a real estate investment destination, which might interest you if you're planning to invest there.
How reliable are essential services like electricity and water supply in Cape Town versus Johannesburg?
Cape Town demonstrates significantly superior essential service reliability through proactive infrastructure investment, while Johannesburg faces recurrent disruptions in both electricity and water supply.
Cape Town has invested heavily in water security through desalination plants, aquifer development, and water reuse facilities following the 2018 water crisis. The city maintains multiple water sources and storage facilities that provide greater supply resilience than Johannesburg's aging infrastructure.
Electricity supply in Cape Town benefits from hydroelectric generation at Steenbras Dam and significant renewable energy investments. The city typically experiences lower load shedding stages than the national grid, with ongoing projects targeting four stages of load shedding protection over three years through independent power purchasing and solar installations.
Johannesburg's essential services suffer from aging infrastructure, cable theft, and maintenance backlogs. Water supply disruptions occur regularly due to pump failures, pipeline breaks, and infrastructure decay. Electricity supply faces challenges from illegal connections causing R3 million daily losses in Soweto alone, plus equipment theft affecting reliability.
Cape Town's service reliability advantage translates directly into property value support, as reliable utilities eliminate the need for expensive backup systems and support consistent quality of life that attracts residents and investors.
What are the long-term capital growth projections for Cape Town relative to Johannesburg?
Cape Town projects annual growth of 3-7% through 2030, significantly outpacing Johannesburg's modest 1.5-3.5% projections, driven by stronger demand fundamentals and supply constraints.
Cape Town's growth trajectory benefits from sustained international demand, domestic semigration trends, and limited developable land in prime areas. The combination of lifestyle appeal, infrastructure investment, and supply constraints creates favorable conditions for sustained appreciation above national averages.
Prime Cape Town areas including the Atlantic Seaboard and City Bowl are projected to achieve 5-8% annual growth, supported by international buyer activity and tourism-driven demand. Emerging neighborhoods like Woodstock and Observatory may deliver higher appreciation as gentrification accelerates.
Johannesburg's growth prospects depend heavily on urban renewal initiatives and proximity to business nodes. While areas like Midrand and Braamfontein show promise with 25-45% potential growth over five years, overall market performance remains constrained by security concerns and infrastructure challenges.
It's something we develop in our South Africa property pack.
The long-term outlook favors Cape Town's diversified economic base, international connectivity, and lifestyle advantages that support sustainable property appreciation beyond economic cycles.
How do lifestyle factors, such as beaches, wine regions, and climate, influence Cape Town's property market compared to Johannesburg's business-driven appeal?
Cape Town's lifestyle advantages including Mediterranean climate, coastal access, and wine regions create sustained residential demand that significantly outweighs Johannesburg's business-centric appeal for property investment.
The city's natural assets including beaches, Table Mountain, and wine regions within 30 minutes drive create unique lifestyle value that cannot be replicated elsewhere in South Africa. These features attract both domestic semigrants seeking improved quality of life and international buyers viewing Cape Town as a lifestyle destination.
Cape Town's climate supports year-round outdoor activities and tourism, creating multiple economic drivers beyond traditional business sectors. The combination of outdoor lifestyle, cultural attractions, and international cuisine establishes the city as South Africa's premier lifestyle destination.
Johannesburg's appeal centers on economic opportunities in finance, mining, and business services. While the city offers career advancement and higher earning potential, lifestyle factors remain secondary to economic considerations for most residents and investors.
The lifestyle differential translates into property premiums, with buyers willing to pay substantial premiums for Cape Town's quality of life benefits. This lifestyle value supports property prices even during economic downturns, creating more resilient investment fundamentals.
International buyers particularly value Cape Town's lifestyle offering, viewing properties as both investment assets and lifestyle purchases that justify premium pricing unavailable in business-focused markets like Johannesburg.
What risks should investors be aware of when buying property in Cape Town compared to Johannesburg?
Cape Town investors face premium pricing, strict zoning regulations, and occasional water scarcity concerns, while Johannesburg presents risks from infrastructure decay, higher crime rates, and governance instability.
Cape Town's primary risks include high entry costs that may limit affordability and liquidity. Premium pricing in sought-after areas can create market access challenges for average investors. Strict zoning laws and heritage restrictions can limit development rights and property modifications in historic areas.
Water scarcity remains a consideration despite massive infrastructure investment, though new desalination and reuse facilities have significantly reduced this risk since the 2018 crisis. Climate change may create future water supply challenges requiring ongoing infrastructure adaptation.
Johannesburg's risks center on declining infrastructure quality, with frequent water and electricity disruptions affecting property values and livability. High crime rates even in premium areas create ongoing security costs and lifestyle limitations that impact long-term property appeal.
Governance challenges in Johannesburg including municipal service delivery problems and maintenance backlogs create uncertainty about future infrastructure reliability. Load shedding impacts are typically more severe than Cape Town due to limited backup power options.
It's something we develop in our South Africa property pack.
Both markets face broader South African economic risks, but Cape Town's diversified economy and international connectivity provide better resilience against domestic economic challenges compared to Johannesburg's dependence on mining and traditional business sectors.
Conclusion
This article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Readers are advised to consult with a qualified professional before making any investment decisions. We do not assume any liability for actions taken based on the information provided.
Cape Town's property market demonstrates clear superiority over Johannesburg across most key investment metrics, from capital appreciation and international demand to infrastructure investment and lifestyle appeal.
While Johannesburg offers higher rental yields and lower entry costs, Cape Town's combination of growth potential, service reliability, and global recognition makes it the stronger long-term investment choice for most property investors.
Sources
- Johannesburg Price Forecasts - The Africanvestor
- Global Property Guide - South Africa Rental Yields
- Best Areas to Invest in South Africa - The Africanvestor
- Cape Town Airbnb Revenue Data - Airbtics
- Cape Town Infrastructure Investment Plans - DA
- African Cities Crime Rates 2025 - Business Day
- South Africa Property Investment Analysis - The Africanvestor
- Cape Town Property Price Growth - RP Realty Plus